Fighting the Same Battle: On the Shooting of Malala Yousfzai

by: Maggie Carr

The recent shooting of Malala Yousafzai has torn me up. Deeply. You’d have to be an automaton to feel anything but grief. But she continues to hang on, and along with the rest of the world, I hope that the doctors at Queen Elizabeth Hospital in the UK are able to save her.

I mourn the disruption, if not the destruction, of a young and very promising life. But violence is often a response to fear, and it gives me hope—real, fierce hope—that the Taliban is so terrified of a teenage girl.

They should be.

Malala Yousafzai stands for everything the Taliban does not. She stands for good books and informed choices and speaking in the public square. Malala stands for principled and fearless resistance to the forces that threaten her very existence as a girl—and in a couple years, as a woman.

I don’t want to rejoice in her martyrdom. A teenager should not have to fight these battles. But now more than ever, we need to recognize that these battles exist.

This is why I find it unspeakably insulting when someone tells me that the fight for women’s rights is no longer relevant. Malala was shot because she was female. She was shot because she had the radical motherfucking idea that women deserve equal access to education. She was shot in the name of male supremacy and female obedience, and she was shot to maintain this power imbalance in a new generation.

No matter how many shitty semantic circles Taliban spokesmen run around it, the fact of the matter is that she was targeted because of her gender. There are many incredible men—including Malala’s own father, Ziauddin—working for education equality in Pakistan; they were not killed, and Malala was targeted on her own school bus. That is not up for debate.

It’s an insult to Malala, and the millions of female victims of gender-related violence, to consider this tragedy in isolation. Women and girls are beaten, tortured, raped, maimed, and killed every minute of every day on every continent.

Though it feels disrespectful to talk about mundane American sexism (whatever that is) in the context of attempted murder, it is vital to the continuation of the female race to recognize that violence is just one derivative of a large, nasty, and well-entrenched framework. Whether it’s with a gun, a bucket of acid, an unwanted sexual advance, or a Supreme Court decision, women are constantly being punished for daring to resist a system that crushes them.

I am sick to my stomach over this story. I am tired of being angry over women being harmed. Most of all, I don’t want to expend any more energy on making a case for feminism when the justification should be clear to everyone. And yet, I feel that I’m doing a disservice to my fellow women by writing and talking about anything else.

I am terrified that yet another generation of precociously bright women has to keep fighting the same battle. They have too much else to do. They have college to attend and books to write and MDs to append to their last names.

So no—I don’t want Malala to survive. Fuck survival. I want her to thrive.

Maggie Carr is a feminist, actor, and sometimes writer living in Brooklyn, NY.  She received her BA in English and American Studies at Boston College, where she was awarded the Janet James Essay Prize in Women’s Studies for her senior thesis on the performativity of storytelling in Eve Ensler’s The Vagina Monologues.  Her interests—both in research and life—include pop music, cheesy musical theatre and vinyasa yoga.  She tweets sporadically at @racecarr.

About these ads

One response to “Fighting the Same Battle: On the Shooting of Malala Yousfzai

  1. I’m glad you wrote on this topic but I hope you have time to read something a bit more critical on the topic of Malala…

    I am upset whenever a young (especially Leftist) writer discusses the terrible plight of Malala Yousafzai but does not mention that her plight is used by pundits and politicians to justify this ELEVEN YEAR invasion of Afghanistan. President Obama who is glorified again and again is literally killing dozens of innocent children and women every month with his drone attacks in neighboring Pakistan\26\story_26-9-2012_pg1_4. There are also countless families in Afghanistan who will be forever changed for massacres by US soldiers (remember Sgt Robert Bales who killed 16 people, mostly children in Khandahar barely a year ago?)

    So again, cool that people care about girls and education in Pakistan.. but BAD that no one is critical of the negative implications of using Malala’s story and other plights of women in Afghanistan thanks to American imperialism.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s